On March 29, 2024, Beyoncé released Cowboy Carter, an album she described as Act II of the Renaissance trilogy and a deliberate exploration of country music's African American roots. The cultural response was immediate, multidirectional, and in many ways more revealing about country music's identity than any single review could be.
What country insiders said, and what the most prominent country establishment didn't say, became its own story.
---
The Artists Who Were On the Album: Celebration and Gratitude
Cowboy Carter featured collaborations with several artists who became the most visible voices in the album's reception.
Dolly Parton, whose iconic 1973 song "Jolene" appears on the album in a reimagined cover, with Parton herself delivering the "Dolly P" interlude that introduces it, responded with immediate warmth. On the day of the album's release, Parton posted a statement: "Wow, I just heard Jolene. Beyoncé is giving that girl some trouble and she deserves it! Love, Dolly P" (ABC News / GMA, March 29, 2024). Parton, who signed as "Dolly P", a playful callback to the interlude character, made clear she had participated knowingly and enthusiastically.
Later, reflecting on Beyoncé's reinterpretation of the song's power dynamics, Parton was reported as noting that Beyoncé's Jolene wasn't going to beg, a distinction Parton appreciated as a songwriter watching her work transformed through another artist's perspective (Forbes, March 29, 2024).
Miley Cyrus, who appears on "II Most Wanted", one of the album's most critically praised tracks, posted on social media expressing gratitude to Beyoncé and the creative team. Cyrus, Parton's goddaughter, was reported to have had the song written years before Beyoncé approached her about the project (Forbes). Her statement underscored the collaborative spirit she experienced.
Post Malone, featured on "Levii's Jeans," shared an Instagram story on release day thanking Beyoncé and describing the album as "beautiful," before later posting a full grid post of the album cover with the message "I Love You Beyoncé" (Forbes).
Tanner Adell, Tiera Kennedy, and Reyna Roberts, three Black female country artists featured on the "Blackbiird" collective, each expressed emotional responses. Kennedy posted "God is so good" on social media. Roberts called Beyoncé her greatest inspiration. Adell, who had been working to establish herself in country, called the moment significant both personally and professionally (Business Insider, March 28, 2024).
---
The Nashville Establishment: The Sound of Silence
The striking counterpoint to these celebratory reactions was what the mainstream Nashville country establishment largely did not say publicly. Established country radio names, male country superstars, and the industry infrastructure that controls the CMA (Country Music Association) apparatus offered minimal public commentary in the immediate aftermath.
This was, as the LA Times documented in its contemporaneous coverage, itself a statement (LA Times, March 29, 2024). In an industry where artists and executives regularly share opinions on releases via social media and press, the careful quiet from portions of Nashville's power structure communicated a posture toward the album, one that became more legible in September 2024, when Cowboy Carter received zero nominations from the Country Music Association (The Guardian, September 10, 2024).
---
Black Country Artists: A Moment of Visibility, With Caution
The Cowboy Carter release accelerated an ongoing conversation about Black artists in country music that had been gaining visibility for years.
Shaboozey, whose career was boosted by Cowboy Carter appearances and who would later chart significantly with his own material, offered a nuanced take, acknowledging the power of the cultural moment while noting how much structural work remained (Business Insider). Breland, another Black country artist interviewed at the time, suggested country music was more "isolated" than other genres, making the breadth of the Cowboy Carter conversation striking.
The context Beyoncé herself provided was documented in an Instagram post ahead of the album's release: "Because of that experience, I did a deeper dive into the history of Country music and studied our rich musical archive", referring to an unnamed experience of not feeling welcomed (Business Insider). Many readers interpreted this as a reference to the backlash following her 2016 CMA Awards performance of "Daddy Lessons" alongside The Chicks.
---
What the Moment Revealed About Country's Identity
Cowboy Carter arrived at a juncture when country music had been negotiating its own identity publicly. The Nashville-to-Pop crossover success of artists like Morgan Wallen had fueled mainstream conversation about what "country" meant commercially versus culturally. Post Malone, Lana Del Rey, and Beyoncé herself had all been discussed in country adjacency before the album's release, a pattern Axios Nashville had documented as a broader crossover phenomenon (Axios Nashville, February 2024).
Cowboy Carter asked a harder question: Who gets to define what country music is, and who gets to be welcomed into it?
The reaction landscape in March 2024 mapped cleanly along those lines. Artists who were embedded in the album responded with warmth. Artists adjacent to the album's collaborative spirit, particularly younger, Black country artists who saw a moment of unprecedented visibility, responded with cautious optimism. The Nashville establishment responded with strategic quiet.
From The Stem documents this cultural moment as it happened, as a record of where the country music community stood in the spring of 2024, when an artist of Beyoncé's stature chose to reckon with the genre on her own terms.
---
FAQ
Q: Did Dolly Parton know "Jolene" would be covered before Cowboy Carter released? Yes. Parton participated in the album as a collaborator, recording the "Dolly P" interlude that introduces Beyoncé's version of "Jolene." She had previously teased her involvement on social media (ABC News).
Q: Did Post Malone consider himself a country artist for appearing on Cowboy Carter? Post Malone's participation was as a featured collaborator on a single track. He expressed admiration for the album publicly but did not characterize his appearance as a country music identity statement.
Q: Was Cowboy Carter nominated at the 2024 CMA Awards? No. Despite its historic commercial and critical reception, Cowboy Carter received no nominations from the Country Music Association in 2024 (The Guardian, September 10, 2024).
Q: Who is Linda Martell, and why does her appearance on Cowboy Carter matter? Linda Martell was one of the first Black women to achieve mainstream success in country music, with a career in the 1970s that was largely overlooked by industry history. Her appearance on Cowboy Carter was widely interpreted as Beyoncé honoring a deliberately marginalized lineage in the genre's history.
Q: Did Beyoncé ever call Cowboy Carter a country album? Beyoncé described it as a "Beyoncé album" and as "Act II" of the Renaissance project. The album's genre categorization, which influenced industry reception and awards eligibility, was a point of ongoing discussion throughout its release cycle.
---
More from the Country desk
Honest, working reporting on the business of independent music from From The Stem.
Visit the Country vertical →