Hayes Carll's What It Is and the Craft of Texas Americana Songwriting

Hayes Carll released What It Is on March 22, 2019, through Dualtone Records, a Nashville-based independent label with a strong catalog in Americana and roots music. The album was his fifth studio record and his first since 2016's Lovers and Leavers. In the intervening years, Carll had built a significant co-writing relationship with Allison Moorer, the Alabama-born singer-songwriter, whom he had also married. Eight of the album's ten tracks were co-written with Moorer, and the result was an album that felt more focused and emotionally specific than anything Carll had released in his prior decade of work.

The Co-Writing Partnership

The Carll-Moorer co-writing relationship brought together two mature, independent-minded songwriters who operated in adjacent but distinct traditions. Carll's roots were in the Texas singer-songwriter circuit, the same lineage that produced Guy Clark, Townes Van Zandt, and Lyle Lovett , writers who treated narrative precision as a musical virtue and who had historically operated outside Nashville's mainstream commercial apparatus. Moorer's background was in Nashville-trained country, though her later career had moved toward literary singer-songwriter territory following the commercial high of her 1990s Mercury Records period.

According to Allmusic's entry on the album, the collaboration deepened Carll's characteristic darkly comic observation with Moorer's precision lyric-writing. The combination produced tracks like "Times Like These," a politically observant song that acknowledged the anxiety of the late 2010s without descending into polemic, and "Nice Things," a piece of economic frustration with a wry enough delivery to avoid the didactic trap.

The co-writing model Carll and Moorer employed was domestic and sustained , writing at home over an extended period rather than in Nashville's professional co-writing session format, where pairs or trios of writers meet for a defined block to produce a single song. That distinction matters. The professional session format optimizes for craft and efficiency; the extended domestic model optimizes for thematic coherence and emotional truth across an album. What It Is sounds like an album by two people who had been living with its material for a long time.

Brad Jones and the Production Approach

Producer Brad Jones brought a deliberate low-key aesthetic to the record. Jones, a Nashville-based musician and producer with a catalog spanning roots, Americana, and indie pop, had produced several important independent records over the preceding decade and was known for a recording philosophy that prioritized natural room sound and organic instrumental texture over polish or contemporary production sheen.

The album was recorded at a relaxed pace with a small core band, and the mix gives each instrument adequate space rather than layering sound to fill gaps. Carll's vocal delivery, which has always been conversational rather than technically showy, sits close in the mix , a placement that suits his storytelling approach and keeps the lyrical content audible without effort.

For independent producers and artists working in the Americana space in 2019, the What It Is sessions represented a viable production model: experienced players, a producer with a clear aesthetic, and an artist-songwriter with enough career security to make the record they wanted rather than one aimed at radio placement or streaming playlisting.

Texas Americana as a Distinct Tradition

Texas Americana occupies a specific position in the broader roots music landscape. The state's songwriter tradition, centered historically on Austin and the Hill Country, developed partly in opposition to Nashville's commercial machinery. The Texas circuit was built on listening rooms, songwriter rounds, and a touring infrastructure that rewarded craft and audience loyalty over radio promotion.

Carll has spent his career working within that tradition while expanding it. His early albums, particularly Trouble in Mind (2008) and KMAG YOYO (2011), established him as a writer capable of comedy, political observation, and emotional depth within the same collection. What It Is extended that range while shedding some of the more comic exterior , the album is warmer, more openly vulnerable, and less interested in playing the wisecracking Texas troubadour than his earlier work.

That evolution is a useful case study in artist development: the willingness to make an album that drops the most accessible parts of an established persona in favor of emotional depth. Carll had enough of a following by 2019 , built through years of hard touring and critical respect , to take that risk. That kind of security, built outside the commercial mainstream, is one of the arguments for the independent touring-and-catalog path.

The Dualtone Relationship

Dualtone Records, founded in 2001 in Nashville, had developed by the late 2010s into one of the more respected independent labels in the Americana and roots space. The label's roster included artists including The Lumineers, Mandolin Orange, and Raul Malo, and its distribution infrastructure gave independent Americana artists access to retail and streaming placement without the constraints of a major-label deal.

Carll's placement with Dualtone reflected a pattern visible across independent Americana in 2018-2019: experienced artists with established fanbases choosing independent label infrastructure that offered marketing support, distribution muscle, and creative autonomy rather than chasing major-label deals that would involve more commercial pressure with less creative control.

For those working in artist development, the Carll-Dualtone relationship illustrates how a mature independent artist can use a boutique label as a functional partner rather than a gatekeeper , leveraging the label's infrastructure while retaining the songwriting and production autonomy that defines the creative output.

The Album's Reception and the Americana Market

What It Is received positive critical attention in the roots and Americana press, with reviewers noting the elevated craft and the emotional directness of the co-writing. The album was recognized by the Americana Music Association in 2019, where Carll was nominated for Americana Duo/Group of the Year for his collaborative work.

The reception illustrated something important about the Americana market circa 2019: the audience for independent roots music was literate enough to notice and reward the kind of craft refinement that What It Is represented. That market had grown through the streaming era, as Americana playlists and streaming-platform curation had made it easier for artists with limited radio access to reach listeners outside their immediate geographic touring range.

Lessons for the Independent Space

Hayes Carll's What It Is holds several practical lessons for artists and producers operating in the independent Americana space. The co-writing relationship was built outside the professional-session model, producing an album with unusual thematic coherence. The production approach , quiet, room-sound-focused, unhurried , served the material without overselling it. The label relationship was one of partnership rather than dependency.

Those choices are available to independent artists at various stages of development. Co-writing with a trusted partner over an extended period produces different results than single-session writing; production that serves the material's emotional register rather than imitating current trends has a longer shelf life; label relationships built on mutual respect and clear creative terms are more sustainable than ones built primarily on advance size.

The record is a quiet argument for the independent path taken seriously.

---

FAQ

Who produced Hayes Carll's What It Is? What It Is was produced by Brad Jones, a Nashville-based musician and producer known for a roots-focused, organic recording approach. Jones has worked across Americana, indie pop, and country throughout his career.

Who did Hayes Carll co-write with on What It Is? Carll co-wrote eight of the album's ten tracks with Allison Moorer, the Alabama-born singer-songwriter who is also his partner. The sustained domestic co-writing relationship shaped the album's thematic coherence.

What label released What It Is? The album was released on Dualtone Records, an independent Nashville label with a strong Americana and roots catalog. Dualtone's other 2019 roster included artists including The Lumineers and Mandolin Orange.

How does What It Is fit into Texas Americana songwriting tradition? Carll operates within the Texas singer-songwriter lineage that includes Guy Clark, Townes Van Zandt, and Lyle Lovett , a tradition that prizes narrative precision and operates largely outside Nashville's commercial radio infrastructure. What It Is represents a maturing phase in that tradition, moving toward emotional vulnerability while retaining the craft-focused lyric approach.

What does the album demonstrate about independent artist development? The record illustrates how a sustained co-writing relationship outside professional session formats, combined with a production approach that serves emotional content, can produce work with longer critical resonance than albums optimized for commercial placement.