The Pedal Steel Revival: How a Nashville Instrument Found Its Way Back Into Indie Americana, 2009-2013

The pedal steel guitar had been the defining sound of classic Nashville country from roughly the 1950s through the 1970s, and its gradual disappearance from mainstream country production in the 1980s and 1990s was one of the most audible markers of the genre's commercial evolution away from its traditional roots. By the early 2000s, pedal steel was largely absent from mainstream country radio, replaced by electric guitars and production elements borrowed from rock and pop.

In the independent Americana and roots world, however, pedal steel had maintained a presence throughout this period, partly because the genre's aesthetic values were explicitly against the trend of mainstream country production. And between approximately 2009 and 2013, something specific happened: the instrument became one of the primary markers of serious Americana identity, a sonic signal that a record was engaged with traditional country values rather than commercial ones.

Why Pedal Steel Matters

The pedal steel's characteristic sound, achieved through a combination of foot pedals and knee levers that change string pitches while the bar maintains contact with the strings, produces a singing, sliding quality that is acoustically unlike any other instrument. Its closest sonic relative is the lap steel guitar, but the pedal mechanism allows pitch changes and vibrato effects that create a distinctly lyrical voice.

In country music, pedal steel had traditionally served several functions: as a lead voice capable of extended melodic statements, as a textural element in chord voicings, and as an emotional intensifier, particularly in ballad contexts. Its absence from mainstream country production was felt as a loss by traditionalists, and its presence in Americana recordings was therefore a statement.

Musicians like Paul Niehaus (who played on many Wilco and various Nashville recordings), Greg Leisz (who worked extensively with Jackson Browne and various California roots artists), and various Nashville session players kept the instrument's tradition alive during the period of mainstream country's steel-free production.

The Sturgill Simpson and Jason Isbell Effect

When Dave Cobb's productions for Sturgill Simpson and Jason Isbell arrived in 2013, both featured prominent pedal steel playing that was central to the sound rather than incidental. The steel's presence was part of what distinguished these records sonically from contemporary mainstream country and aligned them with the classic honky-tonk and country-soul tradition that both artists drew from.

The critical and commercial success of Southeastern and High Top Mountain gave the pedal steel's presence in Americana a specific validation: these were not merely aesthetic choices but elements of production philosophy that had been proven to resonate with the most engaged roots music audiences.

Session players who could play pedal steel with genuine understanding of the country tradition became more sought after in Nashville's independent session scene as a result. The instrument's revival was not purely a matter of fashion; it was a function of a broader values realignment in the roots music world.

The Songwriters and Steel

The pedal steel's specific emotional register made it particularly well-suited to the singer-songwriter tradition that was central to Americana's identity. Its singing quality could provide the harmonic and melodic support that a song's vocal line needed without competing with it, and its ability to sustain notes and create yearning, reaching phrases made it an ideal complement to confessional, emotionally direct songwriting.

Artists like Patty Griffin, Nanci Griffith (who had used steel throughout her career), and various younger singer-songwriters used pedal steel in ways that integrated its traditional sound with contemporary songwriting approaches. The instrument was not merely decorative in these contexts; it was a co-narrator of the emotional content.

Learning and Accessibility

Pedal steel was not an easy instrument to learn. The pedal and lever mechanisms required coordination between both feet and both knees simultaneously while the hands managed the bar position and picking. It was generally considered one of the most technically demanding instruments in country and roots music.

The revival of interest in pedal steel during this period created some growth in the number of musicians learning the instrument, supported by online communities, instructional resources, and the general culture of instrument enthusiasm that the roots music revival promoted. But the instrument's technical demands meant that the pool of genuinely accomplished pedal steel players remained relatively small, which made skilled players in demand.

---

FAQ

What is a pedal steel guitar and how does it differ from a lap steel? A pedal steel guitar has foot pedals and knee levers that change string pitches while the player's right hand manages the metal bar position and picking. This mechanism allows the singing, bending pitch changes that are its characteristic sound. Lap steels lack these pedals and levers.

Why did pedal steel disappear from mainstream Nashville country production? As mainstream country moved toward rock and pop production aesthetics in the 1980s and 1990s, the instrument's traditional sound was associated with older styles that commercial programmers were moving away from.

How did pedal steel become a marker of Americana authenticity? Its presence in records that explicitly positioned themselves against mainstream country production made it a sonic signal of traditional values. Its prominent role in acclaimed Americana productions (particularly Dave Cobb's work with Isbell and Simpson) reinforced this association.

Which session players were most important in maintaining pedal steel's tradition during this period? Paul Niehaus, Greg Leisz, and various Nashville session players kept the tradition alive during the period of mainstream absence, providing the players who were available when Americana's revival created renewed demand.

Is pedal steel difficult to learn? Yes, it is considered one of the most technically demanding instruments in country and roots music, requiring coordination between foot pedals, knee levers, and hand position simultaneously.